Supreme Court Judgment on Sub-classification of Scheduled Castes
Supreme Court Judgment on Sub-classification of Scheduled Castes
Context
- A seven-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court, headed by Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud, delivered a landmark 6:1 majority judgment.
- The judgment allows States to sub-classify Scheduled Castes (SCs) listed in the Presidential List to provide more preferential treatment in public employment and education.
Key Points:
- Sub-classification of SCs:
- The judgment upholds the States’ right to sub-classify SCs to ensure more preferential treatment.
- Chief Justice Chandrachud referred to the Indra Sawhney case, where it was constitutional to classify backward classes into “backward” and “more backward”.
- Principle of Sub-classification:
- Sub-classification is deemed a constitutional requirement to secure substantive equality.
- It is applicable if the social positions within SCs are not comparable.
- Sub-categorization within a class aims to address the inequality among SCs.
- Creamy Layer Principle:
- Four out of seven judges on the Bench recommended the extension of the creamy layer principle to SCs and Scheduled Tribes (STs).
- The principle seeks to exclude affluent individuals or families from reservation benefits to make room for the underprivileged within these classes.
- Justice B.R. Gavai highlighted the necessity of identifying the creamy layer within SCs and STs to achieve real equality.
- Differing Opinions:
- Chief Justice Chandrachud and Justice Misra, along with four other judges, supported the constitutional permissibility of sub-classifying SCs.
- Justice Bela Trivedi dissented, stating that States lack the power to alter the Presidential List of SCs.
- Legal Foundation:
- The power to sub-classify SCs for affirmative action, including reservations, is traced to Articles 15(4) and 16(5) of the Constitution.
- Article 15(4) addresses prohibition of discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, etc.
- Article 16(5) ensures equal opportunity in public employment.
- Concerns and Safeguards:
- The court acknowledged concerns about potential political manipulation to expand vote banks.
- Despite these concerns, the constitutional need to acknowledge and address inter se inequality among SCs was emphasized.
Impact and Implications
- Public Employment and Education:
- Enhanced affirmative action for the most disadvantaged groups within the SC category.
- Greater representation and opportunities for underprivileged segments within SCs.
- Policy Evolution:
- Need for the government to develop policies to identify and exclude the creamy layer within SCs and STs.
- Aim to ensure that benefits of reservation reach the truly needy and underprivileged.
- Legal and Constitutional Discourse:
- Reinforces the principles of substantive equality and affirmative action.
- Sets a precedent for future cases related to classification and reservation policies.
Important Articles and Cases
- Articles:
- Article 15(4): Prohibition of discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth.
- Article 16(5): Equal opportunity in public employment.
- Case:
- Indra Sawhney Case: Recognized the constitutional validity of sub-classifying backward classes.
Preparation Tips
- Prelims Focus:
- Key constitutional articles (15(4), 16(5)).
- Understanding the principle of creamy layer and its implications.
- Significant judgments like Indra Sawhney case.
- Mains Focus:
- Analyze the impact of sub-classification on social justice and equality.
- Discuss the balance between affirmative action and potential political misuse.
- Evaluate the recommendations for extending the creamy layer principle to SCs and STs.
Latest August Current Affairs Quiz
http://www.nalandaias.com/latest-august-2024-current-affairs-quiz/
Aug 2024 Current Affairs-Test I
https://tinyurl.com/augcurrentaffairs
*The CUET UG 2024 results have been announced.*
http://www.nalandaias.com/the-cuet-ug-2024-results/
Manu Bhaker won a bronze medal – Paris 2024 Olympics
http://www.nalandaias.com/manu-bhaker-won-a-bronze-medal-paris-2024-olympics/
The Provincial Armed Constabulary (PAC)]
http://www.nalandaias.com/the-provincial-armed-constabulary-pac/